Argumentative Essay Sample on Women in the Army: Should They Be There or Not?
Last update:
Table of contents
The role of women in the military has been a subject of ongoing debate for decades. While society advocates for gender equality in all aspects of life, the question remains whether women should serve in combat roles. The argument against their inclusion often centers on physical strength, emotional stability, and the potential impact on military efficiency. However, modern advancements, changing societal norms, and real-world examples challenge these traditional views. This essay explores the key arguments for and against women serving in combat positions and evaluates whether gender should be a deciding factor in military service.
Physical Capabilities and Combat Readiness
Combat requires significant physical strength, endurance, and resilience. Historically, men have had an advantage in terms of muscle mass and overall physical capacity. Soldiers are expected to carry heavy loads, engage in hand-to-hand combat, and endure extreme conditions. Studies show that men, on average, have higher upper-body strength and greater endurance, which may give them an edge in combat scenarios.
However, physical standards should be the deciding factor rather than gender. Women who meet the rigorous requirements should be allowed to serve in combat roles. Many military forces, including those in the U.S., have adapted their policies to allow women to take on combat positions, provided they meet the same standards as their male counterparts. Some women have successfully completed elite training programs, proving that gender does not always determine combat capability.
Pro tip
If you’re working on a similar topic and need expert assistance, try our argumentative essay writing service to get a professionally crafted paper.
Emotional and Psychological Resilience
Another argument against women in combat is their emotional response to high-stress situations. War is psychologically demanding, with soldiers facing life-and-death decisions, witnessing violence, and enduring traumatic experiences. Critics argue that women may struggle more with the psychological burden of war.
Yet, research indicates that emotional resilience is not solely determined by gender. Many female soldiers have demonstrated exceptional courage and leadership in high-pressure situations. Moreover, psychological training and support systems exist to help all soldiers, regardless of gender, cope with the mental strain of combat.
Unit Cohesion and Military Efficiency
One concern is that mixed-gender combat units may face challenges related to unit cohesion, discipline, and efficiency. Some argue that traditional gender roles may lead male soldiers to be overly protective of their female counterparts, potentially disrupting mission objectives. Additionally, there are concerns regarding romantic relationships and interpersonal conflicts within mixed units.
While these concerns are valid, proper training and professionalism can mitigate them. Many modern militaries already have mixed-gender units operating successfully. The key to maintaining unit cohesion lies in discipline, leadership, and adherence to military protocols rather than excluding women from combat roles.
Sexual Harassment and Safety Risks
Sexual harassment and assault are serious issues in the military, with female soldiers facing higher risks than their male counterparts. The fear of harassment from fellow soldiers or capture and mistreatment by enemies is often cited as a reason to exclude women from combat.
Rather than restricting women’s roles, the solution lies in stronger policies against harassment, better enforcement of military codes of conduct, and improved training on gender sensitivity. The presence of female officers in leadership positions can also contribute to a safer and more inclusive environment.
Parental Responsibilities and Deployment Challenges
Another challenge is the impact of military service on family life, especially for mothers. Critics argue that women with children should not be deployed to combat zones, as this may negatively affect their families.
However, parenting responsibilities are not exclusive to women. Many male soldiers also leave behind children when deployed. Military policies can offer flexible solutions, such as parental leave, childcare support, and deployment rotations, to ensure both male and female soldiers can balance service and family life.
Historical and Real-World Examples
Despite the challenges, women have played significant roles in combat throughout history. From female snipers in World War II to modern-day fighter pilots and special forces operatives, women have proven their capabilities in battle. Countries like Israel, Canada, and Norway have successfully integrated women into combat roles, demonstrating that gender-inclusive forces can be effective.
Conclusion
The debate over women in combat roles is complex, involving physical, psychological, and logistical considerations. While some concerns are valid, they should not be generalized to exclude all women from combat positions. Military service should be based on individual ability rather than gender. Women who meet the same physical and psychological standards as men should have the opportunity to serve in combat roles. By fostering an inclusive and professional military environment, armed forces can ensure that the best soldiers—regardless of gender—are prepared to defend their nations.
Women in the Military FAQs
Should women be allowed in combat roles?
Yes, as long as they meet the same physical and psychological standards as men. Many modern militaries already have women serving in combat roles successfully.
Do women have the physical strength required for combat?
While men generally have greater physical strength, some women meet or exceed the required physical standards. Combat readiness should be based on ability, not gender.
Does having women in combat affect unit cohesion?
Proper training and discipline ensure unit cohesion, regardless of gender. Many military forces have integrated women into combat roles without significant issues.
What about the risk of sexual harassment?
Sexual harassment is a serious issue that must be addressed with strict policies, training, and leadership accountability, rather than excluding women from service.
Have women historically served in combat?
Yes, women have fought in various wars, including as snipers, pilots, and special forces operatives. Countries like Israel and Canada have successfully integrated women into their military forces.
What impact does military service have on mothers?
Military service affects both mothers and fathers. Supportive policies, such as parental leave and childcare programs, can help balance family responsibilities.
Is integrating women into combat roles costly?
Initial integration may require training and policy adjustments, but the long-term benefits of a more diverse and capable force outweigh the costs.
What steps can be taken to improve women’s safety in the military?
Enforcing strict anti-harassment policies, improving leadership accountability, and ensuring equal training standards can enhance safety for women in the military.
